UPSC Mains Daily Answer Writing Practice (October 16, 2026): Model Answer & Framework

UPSC Mains Daily Answer Writing Practice (October 16, 2026): Model Answer & Framework

Daily UPSC Mains Answer Writing: Question & Model Answer Framework (October 16, 2026)

Today's Mains Question (GS Paper II & III - 15 Marks / 250 Words)

"With the proliferation of on-orbit space control weapons threatening global strategic stability, examine the imperatives for robust multilateral space governance. How can minilateral platforms like BRICS augment India’s strategic posture in securing global commons amidst shifting geopolitical equations in West Asia and outer space?"

1. Decoding the Directive & Demand of the Question

The question requires a nuanced, multi-dimensional analysis bridging international relations, space security, and minilateral diplomacy. It has three core operational dimensions:

  • Part 1 (Contextual Analysis): Examine the nature of emerging security threats in outer space, specifically on-orbit space control weapons (co-orbital anti-satellite systems, directed-energy weapons, and electronic jamming) and the obsolescence of existing legal frameworks.
  • Part 2 (Governance Imperatives): Analyze why traditional bilateral arms control has failed and why binding multilateral frameworks are indispensable for preserving outer space as a peaceful global common.
  • Part 3 (Strategic Integration): Evaluate how India leverages minilateral and multilateral platforms like BRICS to foster strategic autonomy, secure vital supply chains and energy corridors in West Asia, and advocate for equitable governance of outer space without falling into bloc politics.

2. Structural Outline / Skeleton Framework

  • Introduction (30-40 words): Define outer space as the ultimate "global common" and highlight the transition from peaceful scientific exploration to a contested geopolitical theatre due to on-orbit weaponization. Connect with constitutional mandate under Article 51 (promotion of international peace and security).
  • Body Section 1: The Threat Matrix of On-Orbit Space Control Weapons (70-80 words): Discuss active debris mitigation risks, co-orbital satellite tracking, and the inadequacy of the 1967 Outer Space Treaty (OST) which bans WMDs in orbit but remains silent on conventional and dual-use space control technologies.
  • Body Section 2: Imperatives for Multilateral Space Governance (70-80 words): Outline the need for Transparency and Confidence-Building Measures (TCBMs), Prevention of an Arms Race in Outer Space (PAROS) at the UN, and binding norms on responsible behaviour to prevent Kessler Syndrome and orbital gridlock.
  • Body Section 3: BRICS, West Asia, and India's Strategic Calculus (70-80 words): Explain how expanded BRICS (including West Asian heavyweights like UAE, Iran, and Saudi Arabia) provides India with diplomatic leverage to insulate regional trade and energy security while building consensus on technology governance and space cooperation.
  • Way Forward & Recommendation (40-50 words): Advocate for a comprehensive Indo-Pacific and global space code of conduct, strengthening UNCOPUOS, and boosting domestic capabilities through initiatives like IN-SPACe.
  • Conclusion (20-30 words): End with a visionary note emphasizing strategic autonomy and multilateralism as the twin pillars of India's foreign policy in securing Earth and orbital commons.

3. Comprehensive Model Answer

Outer space and interconnected global commons are increasingly transitioning from zones of scientific cooperation into contested strategic frontiers. The recent proliferation of on-orbit space control weapons—such as co-orbital interceptors, laser dazzlers, and electronic jamming platforms—has elevated the risk of orbital warfare. This technological shift threatens critical infrastructure ranging from global communication networks to satellite-based navigation systems, making robust multilateral governance an existential imperative for modern nation-states.

The Evolving Threat Matrix in Orbital Space:
The foundational legal architecture governing space—primarily the 1967 Outer Space Treaty (OST)—was drafted during a bipolar Cold War paradigm. It explicitly prohibits the placement of Weapons of Mass Destruction (WMDs) in orbit but contains glaring loopholes regarding conventional, cyber, and dual-use on-orbit kinetic and non-kinetic weapons. Modern space-faring nations are deploying co-orbital satellites capable of shadowing, disabling, or physically destroying adversarial assets. Without updated verification regimes, accidental escalation in orbit could trigger catastrophic cascading debris clouds (Kessler Syndrome), rendering vital orbits unusable for generations.

Imperatives for Multilateral Governance:
Given the borderless nature of orbital mechanics, unilateral deterrence is insufficient. Multilateral governance is imperative to establish:

  • Clear Norms of Responsible Behaviour: Differentiating between peaceful satellite servicing missions and offensive space control capabilities.
  • Transparency and Confidence-Building Measures (TCBMs): Mandatory pre-launch notifications, orbital data sharing, and institutionalized communication channels during orbital anomalies.
  • Revitalization of PAROS: Strengthening the UN Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space (UNCOPUOS) and the UN Office for Disarmament Affairs (UNODA) to negotiate legally binding treaties against space weaponization.

BRICS, West Asia, and India’s Strategic Posture:
In this era of multipolar flux, minilateral coalitions like BRICS serve as critical diplomatic multipliers for India. With the inclusion of major West Asian powers (UAE, Saudi Arabia, Iran, and Egypt), BRICS represents a vital bridge linking South Asia, the Global South, and West Asian energy corridors.

India’s engagement within BRICS facilitates plurilateral consensus on critical emerging technologies, including secure satellite communications, space-based remote sensing for agriculture and disaster management, and joint opposition to weaponization of global commons. Concurrently, stability in West Asia is paramount for India’s energy security and diaspora welfare. By utilizing BRICS as a platform for dialogue rather than an anti-Western bloc, India maintains strategic autonomy, balancing partnerships with Western space agencies (via the Artemis Accords) while advocating for inclusive, equitable multilateral norms for outer space at global forums.

Way Forward:
India must champion a global Code of Conduct for Outer Space Activities, combining its indigenous technological prowess (demonstrated via Mission Shakti and ISRO's commercial arm, NewSpace India Limited) with proactive multilateral diplomacy. Fostering a rules-based order on Earth is inextricably linked to maintaining peace in the heavens.

Conclusion:
As outer space becomes the new high ground of geopolitical competition, India’s foreign policy must continue to blend pragmatic minilateralism (through BRICS and Quad) with staunch multilateralism. Guided by the ethos of Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam, India remains uniquely positioned to steer global governance toward preserving outer space as a peaceful, shared asset for humanity's sustainable future.

4. Value Addition Box (Schemes, Data & Committees)

Category Key Frameworks / Instruments / Data UPSC Utility & Application
International Treaties Outer Space Treaty (1967), Liability Convention (1972), Registration Convention (1975). Essential for citing legal foundations and regulatory gaps in space security questions.
Global Forums & Resolutions UNCOPUOS, PAROS (Prevention of an Arms Race in Outer Space) UN General Assembly resolutions. Highlights institutional mechanisms for multilateral space diplomacy.
Constitutional & Strategic Doctrine Article 51 (Directive Principles of State Policy - International Peace), India's Draft Space-based Doctrine. Binds domestic constitutional obligations with India's peaceful foreign policy posture.
Minilateral Leverage BRICS Space Consortium, Indian Space Policy 2023, IN-SPACe framework. Demonstrates synergy between domestic institutional reforms and plurilateral technological cooperation.

ЁЯПЫ️ Official Government & Policy Updates (PIB Gazette Connect)

Key national initiatives, Cabinet & Ministry releases aligned with GS-2 and GS-3:

Comments

Post a Comment